A naughty or nice meter for December, with the child's name on it
A naughty or nice meter with the child's name over the scale and a pointer that slides between NAUGHTY and NICE. How families use it through December, how the elf moves it overnight, and how it carries on after Christmas as a mood meter.
The naughty-or-nice idea is older than most of the props. "He's making a list, he's checking it twice" comes from "Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town", published in 1934. The elf that watches from a shelf is much newer: The Elf on the Shelf, a 2005 picture book sold with a toy elf, has the elf fly to the North Pole each night to report whether the children were naughty or nice. It has its critics too, from writers who dislike tying good behaviour to presents to those who object to teaching children that being watched is normal. Worth knowing when you decide how seriously to play it.
A naughty or nice meter on the shelf is the gentler version: the child can see where they stand, and it moves back as easily as it moves forward. It works with an elf too, as an elf naughty nice scale that moves overnight. This post covers what the meter is, how families use it through December, and what it becomes in January.
What the meter is
The naughty or nice meter is a board with the child's name and a heading at the top, LIAM'S and NAUGHTY OR NICE METER by default. Under them runs a scale from NAUGHTY at one end to NICE at the other, and a small line at the bottom: CHECKED DAILY BY THE NORTH POLE.
A pointer with a star, a heart, an arrow or a dot slides along the scale. It runs in a channel whose edges lean in over it, so it can't be lifted out, and a cap pressed into the end of the channel shuts it in. It can't be lost behind the sofa or pulled off by a younger sibling. It should slide with a push and stay where it is left.
The meter leans back on two feet that slot on, for a shelf or a mantelpiece, or hangs on the wall from two holes. It is 150 to 250 mm wide.
Using it through December
The meter starts in the middle on the first of December. From there it moves with the day's behaviour: a little towards NICE for tidying up without being asked, a little the other way for a fight over the remote. A parent can move it at bedtime, in front of the child, or leave it to the morning.
What makes it work is that it moves back just as easily. A bad afternoon is one push towards NAUGHTY, and a good evening undoes it. The point is that the pointer is never stuck.
The elf's overnight move
Families with an elf can hand the meter over to it. The child goes to bed with the pointer in one place and wakes to find it has moved in the night, with the elf sitting beside it. A move towards NICE after a good day is a reward of its own. Pair it with an elf door and the elf has somewhere to come and go from.
Christmas Eve
On Christmas Eve the pointer goes to NICE, however the month went. It is a nice moment to do with the child before bed, along with putting out the Santa stop here sign so the sleigh finds the house. For a house without a chimney, Santa's magic key goes on the front door the same evening. All three can carry the same names.
After Christmas, a mood meter
Every word on the meter can be changed: the name, the heading, the two ends of the scale and the bottom line. So the same design carries on all year as something else. MOOD METER with GRUMPY and SUNNY, hung on a bedroom door. HOW BUSY with COME IN and NOT NOW, on a desk. A spice meter for the curry, or a hunger meter for the cat.
Printing it
The board and its words print flat, face up, with no supports and no glue. They are two colours in stacked layers: change filament when the words start, and no multi-colour printer is needed. The pointer and its cap print separately in a third colour that stands out. Slide the pointer in from the end of the channel, then press in the cap. If the pointer is stiff or loose, change the clearance and reprint only the pointer and the cap, which are small.
Selling them
Take names to order from November. A family with two or three children may want one each, and a set with a matching Santa stop here sign makes a December bundle. For more ideas in the same season, the Christmas decorations page lists the rest. After Christmas, relist the meter as a mood meter. In listings, describe it as working with "an elf": The Elf on the Shelf is a brand name, and names like that can be trade marks.
The right to sell what you print comes with the Seller plan.
Planning what to make next? Browse personalised print ideas by occasion, or work out prices, party orders and colour changes with the free maker tools.