How much profit is in a 3D printed keychain? Etsy, Instagram and craft fairs compared
The same personalised keychain earns very different money on Etsy, through Instagram DMs and at a market stall. Real numbers for each, and what to charge so every order pays.
"How much should I charge?" is the first question almost every new seller asks, and the honest answer is: it depends where you sell. The fees, the postage and the time you spend per order change from one channel to the next, and they matter far more than the filament.
To show how much, we priced one item, a personalised name keychain, for three ways of selling it. Every number below comes from our free 3D print profit calculator, so you can open it and put in your own.
The keychain
- Filament: 8 g of PLA at $20 a kilo, plus 10% for failed prints. That is 18 cents.
- Printer time: 45 minutes on a Bambu Lab A1, assuming an average draw of about 100 W, with 30 cents an hour for wear and spare parts. That is 24 cents.
- Your time: 10 minutes per order (messages, the file, the proof picture, setting up the plate) and 5 minutes per keychain (removing, checking, bagging), at $20 an hour. That is $5.00.
- Packing: 60 cents for a bag and a card.
The filament and the electricity together come to 42 cents. Your time is twelve times that. If you price by weight you are giving your time away.
Etsy: $14, with $5.78 left
On Etsy in the US you pay a $0.20 listing fee per item sold, a 6.5% transaction fee that also applies to the postage you charge (Etsy's fee page), and 3% plus $0.25 for payment processing on a US bank account. With the buyer paying $4.50 postage at checkout and a 40% margin target, the calculator suggests $14.00.
| Etsy | |
|---|---|
| Price | $14.00 |
| Buyer pays postage | $4.50 |
| Fees | $2.21 |
| Costs, including the postage you pay | $10.51 |
| Profit | $5.78 |
Two things change that number a lot:
- Charging $10 instead. Profit falls to $2.16, about 13 minutes of your time at your own rate. Underpricing by $4 throws away nearly two thirds of the profit.
- Offsite Ads. When a sale comes from one of Etsy's ads, another 15% comes off the order total (12% for shops that made at least $10,000 on Etsy in the past 365 days, per the same fee page). At $14 your profit drops from $5.78 to $3.00. You can't choose which sales come from ads, so if many of yours do, price for it. The calculator has a tick box for it.
Instagram and WhatsApp: $11.50, with $4.72 left
Sell through DMs with a card payment link and the fees drop to the payment provider's rate; we used 2.9% plus 30 cents, a common US online card rate. Check your own provider's pricing page. The same keychain needs only $11.50 for the same 40% margin, and keeps $4.72.
Lower fees mean you can charge less and still earn about the same, which matters when a buyer has found you through a friend rather than a search. A bank transfer usually costs nothing, and in India UPI payments to a merchant of up to ₹2,000 carry no merchant fee; a 0.4% rate applies above that from 15 October 2026 (summary of the UPI rules).
The catch is the messages. A DM order often takes longer than 10 minutes: questions about colours, a spelling to check, a picture to approve. Count it honestly. Our guide to custom orders on Instagram and WhatsApp has a message flow that cuts most of that back and forth.
Craft fair: $7.50, with $3.27 left
A market stall works differently. There is no postage and much less time per order: no messages, the keychain is printed in advance, and you hand it over in a 30-cent paper bag. Set per-order time to 2 minutes and per-item time to 3, add a $60 stall fee spread over the 40 keychains you expect to sell, and use a card reader at 2.6% plus 15 cents (Square's US in-person rate on its free plan).
The suggested price falls to $7.50, with $3.27 profit on each. That is less per piece, and the whole stall only pays if you sell close to the number you planned for. If you sell fewer than you expect, the stall fee per keychain rises quickly: put the number you actually sold into the calculator after the event.
Our guide to selling at craft fairs and markets covers what to bring and how to lay out the table.
Bulk orders: price the batch, not the piece
Party favours, school tags and office name plates come in batches, and a batch is much cheaper to make per piece. The messages, the setup and the fixed part of the fees happen once per order instead of once per item.
For 40 place cards sold through a payment link, the calculator suggests $10.00 for a single card but $3.50 each for the batch of 40, a $140 order with $56.56 profit at the same margin. The price table in the calculator shows 1, 10, 25, 50 and 100 pieces side by side, so you can quote a party planner on the spot.
If you print a full plate at once, divide the plate's print time by the number of pieces on it before you enter it. Our guide to school name tags in bulk walks through a class order step by step.
Send the price, not your workings
Once you know the price, the calculator can make a quote link: a page that shows the customer the item, the quantity, the price, postage, a note and a date it is valid until, and nothing about your costs or margin. You can lock it with a passphrase you send separately, which is worth doing when the note has the customer's details in it.
What to take from this
- Your time is the biggest cost. Count the minutes, including the messages.
- Fees decide the price more than filament does. The same keychain needs $14 on Etsy and $11.50 through a payment link to earn about the same.
- Markets trade margin for volume. Lower prices, more sales, and a stall fee that only works if you sell enough.
- Batches change everything. Quote bulk orders per batch, never as single items multiplied.
Open the 3D print profit calculator, save your printer and costs once, and every price after that takes seconds. Then pick a design: name keychains, bag and school tags and wedding and event details are where most personalised orders start.
Planning what to make next? Browse personalised print ideas by occasion, or work out prices, party orders and colour changes with the free maker tools.